These song lists document any changes that the production went through aside from the opening night song list.
From week of April 5, 1954
Prologue
- Harlequinade .... Harlequin, Puncinello, Pierrot, Pierrette, Columbine, Pierrettes, Pierrots
Act One
- The Coronation: Queen for a Day .... Miss Reingold, The Four Queens, The Bridegrooms
- My Cousin Who? .... David, Butlers, Witch Doctors, Maids, Rebecca, Louise
- You're So Much a Part of Me .... The Pierrette of 1953, The Pierrot of 1953
- I Dare to Dream .... Sung by Judy Lynn and Tony Bavaar
- The Cello .... The Cellist
- Don Brown's Body .... Mike Hammer, Sally Duprey, Man, Chorus (Siri, Colleen Hutchins, Joan Morton, Tina Louise, Bob Kole, Jay Harnick, Larry Kert, Ronald Cecill)
- Mark Twain .... Sung by Harry Belafonte, with Millard Thomas, Guitarist
- The Nightingale and the Rose .... Introduced by Colleen Hutchins; The Story Teller, The Student, The Prince, The Coquette, The Nightingale, The Guests at the Ball
- European Express .... Mrs. A, Mr. B
- .... The Song Plugger, and Ronald Cecill, Jay Harnick, Larry Kert, Bob Kole
- Mammy Songs .... Ralph McWilliams and Kenneth Urmston
- Rhythm Songs .... George Vosburgh, Imelda DeMartin, Lee Becker, Greb Lober, Gwen Neilson
- Torch Songs .... Toni Wheelis, Illona Murai, Margot Myers, Hank Brunjes, Gerard Leavitt, Skeet Guenther
- Patriotic Songs .... Elaine Dunn
- Page 11 ? Orson Bean
- Merry Little Minuet .... Orson Bean
- Anema e Core .... The Minstrel, The Countess, Courtiers (Larry Kert, Jay Harnick, Skeet Guenther, Hank Brunjes)
- Hope You Come Back .... (Introduced by Carleton Carpenter and Tina Louse); Meg, Beth, Jo, Amy, Marmee, Laurie
Act Two
- Ziegfeldiana: If Every Month Were June .... Sung by Celia Lipton and Tony Bavaar; The Spring Bride, The Summer Bride, The Autumn Bride, The Winter Bride, The Bouquet, The Train Bearers
- Which Witch? .... Sung by Hermione Gingold
- La Loge (Renoir) .... The Man in the Box
- Fini .... Sung by Judy Lynn
- Cartoon .... First Secretary, Second Secretary, The New Manager
- Acorn in the Meadow .... Sung by Harry Belafonte
- .... Sung and Danced by Elaine Dunn and Carleton Carpenter
- .... The Lady, The Butler
- Page 8 ? Orson Bean
- The Chinese monologue .... Orson Bean
- .... Sung by Harry Belafonte; Danced by Illona Murai, Hank Brunjes, Jacqueline Mickles, Colleen Hutchins and The "Almanac" Dancers
- .... Bobo, Cornelius, Fifi
- .... Sung by Tony Bavaar and Judy Lynn
- Finale .... The Entire Company