These song lists document any changes that the production went through aside from the opening night song list.
From playbill for the week of December 10, 1951
This post-opening list of musical numbers lists specific characters singing "Movin'," rather than listing it as being sung by the Miners (as in the playbill from opening week on Broadway).
Act One
- Overture .... Orchestra
- I'm on My Way .... Sung by Steve, Jake, Mooney, Zen, Yuy, Sandy, Crocker, Sloane and the Miners
- Rumson .... Sung by Jake
- What's Goin' On Here? .... Sung by Jennifer
- I Talk to the Trees .... Sung and danced by Julio and Jennifer
- They Call the Wind Maria .... Sung by Steve and Miners; Danced by Pete and Miners
- I Still See Elisa .... Sung by Ben Rumson
- How Can I Wait? .... Sung by Jennifer
- Trio .... Sung by Elizabeth, Sarah and Jacob Woodling
- Rumson .... Sung by Jake
- In Between .... Sung and danced by Ben
- Whoop-Ti-Ay! .... Sung and danced by Ben, Elizabeth and Miners
- How Can I Wait? (Reprise) .... Sung by Jennifer and Julio
- Carino Mio .... Sung by Julio and Jennifer
- There's a Coach Comin' In .... Sung by the Miners
- Finaletto .... Danced by the Fandangos and Miners
Act Two
- Hand Me Down That Can O' Beans .... Sung by Jake and Miners
- Rope Dance .... Fandangos and Pete and Yvonne
- Can-can .... Danced by Suzanne and Rocky and Fandangos and Miners
- Another Autumn .... Sung by Julio; Danced by Yvonne and Pete
- Movin' .... Sung by Ed, Bill, Joe, Sam, Jack, Jasper, Johansen, Zen, Yuy
- I'm on My Way (Reprise) .... Sung by the Miners
- All for Him .... Sung by Jennifer
- Wand'rin' Star .... Sung by Ben
- I Talk to the Trees (Reprise) .... Sung by Jennifer
- Strike! .... Sung by Steve, Jasper and Jake
- Wand'rin' Star (Reprise) .... Sung by Jake, Steve, Sandy and the Miners
- Finale